Headline
New Title
Family Owned and Operated Since 1932
Catering and Wine Delivery to Your Door
Over 2000 Wines From Around the World
Authentic Italian-American Cuisine
Italian Market Menu
Akron, OH
Family Owned and Operated Since 1932
Catering and Wine Delivery to Your Door
Over 2000 Wines From Around the World
Authentic Italian-American Cuisine
Hours:
Discover Papa Joe's Authentic Italian Market Menu
When you're looking for authentic Italian flavors in Akron, OH, Papa Joe's Italian Market and Wine Shoppe has everything you need. Our Italian Market Menu(see below) features a carefully selected assortment of traditional meats, cheeses, pantry staples, prepared foods, and desserts that bring the taste of Italy to your table. Whether you're planning a family dinner, stocking up on specialty ingredients, or ordering food for a gathering, you'll find quality options for every occasion.
Need ingredients for tonight's dinner or catering for your event? Reach out to us today.
Your Destination for Italian Specialties
Your Destination for Italian Specialties
Great meals start with quality ingredients. At Papa Joe's, you'll find a wide selection of authentic Italian products and prepared foods that make it easy to enjoy traditional flavors without traveling far. From everyday essentials to specialty items, our market is stocked with products chosen for their quality and taste.
Our market offerings include:
- Fresh Italian meats and cheeses
- Imported pasta and sauces
- Specialty Italian ingredients
- Ready-made trays in multiple sizes
- House-made prepared foods
- All dressings are homemade, gluten-free, and preservative-free
- Traditional Italian desserts
- We pride ourselves on friendly service and making every customer feel like family
Whether you're creating a homemade Italian feast or picking up prepared favorites for a busy weeknight, you'll find plenty of delicious options to choose from.
Why Shop at Papa Joe's?
For generations, Papa Joe's has been a trusted destination for Italian food lovers throughout Northeast Ohio. As a locally and family-owned business serving the community since 1932, we're committed to providing exceptional products and personalized service.
Here's what sets us apart:
- Authentic Italian products and flavors
- High-quality meats, cheeses, and specialty ingredients
- Freshly prepared foods made with care
- Premium wines available at retail prices
- Friendly, knowledgeable customer service
We take pride in helping our customers find the perfect ingredients, prepared foods, and specialty items to bring family and friends together around great food.
Contact Us
Ready to experience authentic Italian flavors from our market in Akron, OH? Need fresh ingredients, specialty items, or catering trays for your next gathering? We've got you covered. Our team is here Tuesday through Sunday to help you find exactly what you're looking for.
Contact us today to place your order or learn more about our Italian Market offerings.
Your Destination for Italian Specialties
Great meals start with quality ingredients. At Papa Joe's, you'll find a wide selection of authentic Italian products and prepared foods that make it easy to enjoy traditional flavors without traveling far. From everyday essentials to specialty items, our market is stocked with products chosen for their quality and taste.
Our market offerings include:
- Fresh Italian meats and cheeses
- Imported pasta and sauces
- Specialty Italian ingredients
- Ready-made trays in multiple sizes
- House-made prepared foods
- All dressings are homemade, gluten-free, and preservative-free
- Traditional Italian desserts
- We pride ourselves on friendly service and making every customer feel like family
Whether you're creating a homemade Italian feast or picking up prepared favorites for a busy weeknight, you'll find plenty of delicious options to choose from.
Why Shop at Papa Joe's?
For generations, Papa Joe's has been a trusted destination for Italian food lovers throughout Northeast Ohio. As a locally and family-owned business serving the community since 1932, we're committed to providing exceptional products and personalized service.
Here's what sets us apart:
- Authentic Italian products and flavors
- High-quality meats, cheeses, and specialty ingredients
- Freshly prepared foods made with care
- Premium wines available at retail prices
- Friendly, knowledgeable customer service
We take pride in helping our customers find the perfect ingredients, prepared foods, and specialty items to bring family and friends together around great food.
Your Personal Wine Consultant
Owner and Wine Consultant Jeff is at your service to help pair your favorite dishes with exclusive selections from our extensive wine cellar. Mix and match to suit all your needs. Receive a 10% discount on 6 bottles or more! Please inquire here with questions or to schedule a private appointment!
We will get back to you as soon as possible.
Please try again later.
Ready to experience authentic Italian flavors from our market in Akron, OH? Need fresh ingredients, specialty items, or catering trays for your next gathering? We've got you covered. Our team is here Tuesday through Sunday to help you find exactly what you're looking for.
Contact us today to place your order or learn more about our Italian Market offerings.
Contact Us
We will get back to you as soon as possible.
Please try again later.
Contact Us:
Your Personal Wine Consultant
Owner and Wine Consultant Jeff is at your service to help pair your favorite dishes with exclusive selections from our extensive wine cellar. Mix and match to suit all your needs. Receive a 10% discount on all case purchases! Please inquire here with questions or to schedule a private appointment!
Contact Us
We will get back to you as soon as possible.
Please try again later.
Catering Menu
Chilled Appetizers
Roasted red peppers, marinated artichoke hearts, pepperonicini, salami, capicola, a blend of olives & tomato mozzarella salad, served with crackers
Medium (Serves 20-25) $99
Large (Serves 25-40) $124
Five local cheeses, broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, cucumbers, bell peppers & celery, served with crackers and housemade ranch
Small (Serves 12-20) $60
Medium (Serves 20-35) $80
Large (Serves 35-60) $100
Priced per shrimp. Served with housemade cocktail sauce
Priced by weight. Papa's Pasta Salad, Broccoli Salad, Kidney Bean Salad, Tortellini Salad, Tomato & Mozzarella Salad.
Ham & Provolone, Turkey & Provolone, Chicken Salad & Tuna Salad on Fresh Rolls
Medium (24 sandwiches) $78
Large (44 sandwiches) $130
Served with fresh pita chips. (Serves 20-25)
Served with housemade ciabatta crostini
Medium (Serves 15-20) $59
Large (Serves 25-40) $79
Warm Appetizers
Housemade meatballs with your choice of barbeque or marinara sauce
Medium (48 meatballs) $78
Large (78 meatballs) $108
Locally made Italian sausage tossed with peppers, onions, & tomatoes
Medium (About 48 Pieces) $99
Large (About 72 Pieces) $149
Served with fresh pita chips (Serves 20-25)
Served with fresh pita chips (Serves 20-25)
Light and crispy
Medium (40 pieces) $75
Large (60 pieces) $105
Choice of barbecue or buffalo sauce
Medium (50 wings) $99
Large (75 wings) $149
Buffet Menu
2 Main Entrees
1 Side Dish
$28.99 Per Adult | $14 Per Child (11 & Under)
3 Main Entrees
2 Side Dish
$35.99 Per Adult | $16 Per Child (11 & Under)
All buffets served with a salad, rolls, and butter.
Add an additional side $3.50 per person
Add an additional entree $5.50 per person
Buffet Entree Choices
Locally made Italian sausage tossed with peppers, onions, & tomatoes
Thinly sliced roast beef served with a delicious au jus
(Additional $2.00 per person)
Lightly seasoned & broiled to perfection
A local favorite, tender chicken sauteed in our classic lemon butter sauce
(Additional $2.00 per person)
Grilled chicken breast, basted with honey Dijon mustard, topped with candied pecans
Lightly breaded chicken cutlets topped with arugula, evoo, lemon & parmesan
Chicken medallions sauteed with mushrooms in a rich marsala wine sauce
Italian marinated grilled chicken breast
Fresh pasta layered with Tuscan bechamel, housemade meat sauce, parmesan reggiano & mozzarella cheese
Fresh pasta and thin-sliced fried eggplant layered with tuscan bechamel, housemade Marinara sauce, Parmesan Reggiano & mozzarella cheese
Hand-rolled with ricotta, organic spinach & parmesan cheese, baked with Alfredo and topped with mozzarella cheese & fresh tomato bruschetta
Penne pasta served with housemade marinara sauce
Penne pasta tossed with seasonal vegetables, extra virgin olive oil & garlic, topped with parmesan cheese
Tender pasta in a rich & creamy housemade cheese sauce
Buffet Side Dishes
Add a meatball $3.99
Add a sausage $4.99
Dessert Trays
A delicious assortment of lemon bars, hand-filled cannolis, fresh baked brownies & cookies
Small $55
Medium $85
Large $120
Freshly baked fudge brownies
Small (12 pieces) $39
Medium (24 pieces) $69
Large (40 pieces) $89
An assortment of fresh cookies baked daily in our Italian market
Small (20 cookies) $49
Medium (30 cookies) $62
Large (50 cookies) $99
Individual Desserts
Hand filled with chocolate chip cream
Mini Cannoli (Each) $3
Large Cannoli (Each) $6
Fluffy, jumbo rice Krispies, topped with sprinkles
Sangria & Wine
Housemade sangria, served chilled
Serves up to 45 guests
A light & refreshing white wine blend with notes of citrus & peach
A fresh, full-bodied red wine blend with notes of berry
A Wonderful White - La Fiera Pinot Grigio $19.99
A Full Bodied Red - Montepulciano D'Abruzzo $20.99
Delicious and priced right!
Delivery Distance Fees
Elegant Disposable or China Options
Add-Ons
10% auto-gratuity on deliveries $200 or more
20% auto-gratuity on all served events
Homemade Lasagna Menu
Lasagna
Our Pan, Your Oven!
Our famous lasagna is made fresh daily
*Please call ahead for large lasagnas
Serving Sizes:
-Mini: serves 2-3
-Small: serves 6-8
-Large: serves 24-28
Italian Market Menu
Lasagna
Our Pan, Your Oven!
Our famous lasagna is made fresh daily
*Please call ahead for large lasagnas
Serving Sizes:
-Mini: serves 2-3
-Small: serves 6-8
-Large: serves 24-28
Housemade Soup
Available in half pint, pint, and quart
Fried Chicken
Our best kept secret!
Tuscan marinated, hand-breaded & fried to golden perfection
*Please order ahead*
8 pieces
4 pieces
Salad
Always fresh!
Our salads are made fresh every morning
Serving Sizes:
-Mini: serves 2-3
-Small: serves 6-8
-Large: serves 24-28
Dressing and Sauce
Made fresh daily, gluten-free, and preservative-free
Available in half pint, pint, and quart
Italian Favorites
Serving Sizes:
-Mini: serves 2-3
-Small: serves 6-8
-Large: serves 24-28
Appetizers (Heat and Serve)
Shrimp Cocktail
Jumbo 8/10 shrimp steamed to perfection, served with housemade cocktail sauce
12 shrimp
24 shrimp
48 shrimp
Scoopable Salad
Party Trays
Serving Sizes:
-Small: serves 12
-Medium: serves 25
-Large: serves 40+
Mini Sandwiches
Ham & provolone, turkey & provolone, chicken salad & tuna salad served on italian rolls
Oven Ready
Dessert Trays
Fresh Cookies
An assortment of daily and seasonal flavors
Fudge Brownies
Decadent, freshly baked brownies
Ultimate Assorted
Gourmet lemon bars, hand-filled cannolis, freshly baked fudge brownies & cookies
Cannoli Tray
Priced a la carte
Italian Market Menu
Lasagna
Our Pan, Your Oven!
Our famous lasagna is made fresh daily
*Please call ahead for large lasagnas
Serving Sizes:
-Mini: serves 2-3
-Small: serves 6-8
-Large: serves 24-28
Housemade Soup
Available in half pint, pint, and quart
Fried Chicken
Our best kept secret!
Tuscan marinated, hand-breaded & fried to golden perfection
*Please order ahead*
8 pieces
4 pieces
Salad
Always fresh!
Our salads are made fresh every morning
Serving Sizes:
-Mini: serves 2-3
-Small: serves 6-8
-Large: serves 24-28
Dressing and Sauce
Made fresh daily and gluten-free
Available in half pint, pint, and quart
Italian Favorites
Serving Sizes:
-Mini: serves 2-3
-Small: serves 6-8
-Large: serves 24-28
Appetizers (Heat and Serve)
Shrimp Cocktail
Jumbo 8/10 shrimp steamed to perfection, served with housemade cocktail sauce
12 shrimp
24 shrimp
48 shrimp
Scoopable Salad
Party Trays
Serving Sizes:
-Small: serves 12
-Medium: serves 25
-Large: serves 40+
Mini Sandwiches
Ham & provolone, turkey & provolone, chicken salad & tuna salad served on italian rolls
Oven Ready
Dessert Trays
Fresh Cookies
An assortment of daily and seasonal flavors
Fudge Brownies
Decadent, freshly baked brownies
Ultimate Assorted
Gourmet lemon bars, hand-filled cannolis, freshly baked fudge brownies & cookies
Cannoli Tray
Priced a la carte
